markasjunk2

[dziobak]

@JohnDoh

I have problem with markasjunk2. Every message that I'm marking is not learned

Code Select Expand

[08-Apr-2010 15:16:17 +0200]: /usr/local/bin/sa-learn --configpath=/usr/local/etc/mail/spamassassin/ --spam /usr/local/www/roundcube/temp/rcmSALearnlefltf
[08-Apr-2010 15:16:17 +0200]: array (
  0 => 'Learned tokens from 0 message(s) (1 message(s) examined)',
)
but when i use the same command from shell but on existing message in maildir format, it works OK

Code Select Expand

sa-learn --configpath=/usr/local/etc/mail/spamassassin/ --spam /tmp/testmessage
Learned tokens from 1 message(s) (1 message(s) examined)
Maybe there is a way to change localization of %f variable to real message in maildir format?

Could you help me?

[Martian]

See here:

http://www.roundcubeforum.net/7-third-party-contributions/46-api-based-plugins/5957-markasjunk2-sa-learn-problem.html

[dziobak]

I don't see the answer for my problem in there.
I don't have any errors in markasjunk2 log. I think there is a problem in mail formats. I use a maildir format and i think markasjunk2 uses mbox.
If php code knows a file name of a mail file, it could set in %f variable the location of that file. or it can create in RC_DIR/temp a maildir format file.

[JohnDoh]

if you want to see the file its creating then try commenting out

Code Select Expand

unlink($tmpfname); at the bottom of drivers/cmd_learn.php. that way the temp file wont be deleted after the command has run and you can compare the contents with your test file.

[dziobak]

Yes the files are creating and there are the same as original

Maybe I have something wrong with my RC config but $_SESSION['username'] have only name before '@' (not '[email protected]' but 'test'), so I have added some lines in cmd_learn.php and change the command to

Code Select Expand

/usr/local/bin/sa-learn --username=%l --configpath=/usr/local/etc/mail/spamassassin/ --spam %f but it doesn't work either.
29     $command = str_replace('%u', $_SESSION['username'], $command);
30
31     if (strpos($_SESSION['username'], '@') !== false) {
32         $parts = explode("@", $_SESSION['username'], 2);
33
34         $command = str_replace(array('%l', '%d'), array($parts[0], $parts[1]), $command);
35     }
36 +   else {
37 +       $command = str_replace('%l', $_SESSION['username'], $command);
38 +   }

[JohnDoh]

sorry i dont get it, if your username doesnt contain an @ then %l and %d are irrelevent, just use %u if thats what you want.

[dziobak]

what would happen when I login to roundcube as [email protected]? the session user name will be [email protected] but i want to have only test. So when I login as [email protected] it will execute the if statement but when i login as test it will execute else statement. In both cases I have username test

but this doesn't solve the learning problem...

[JohnDoh]

i still dont get it, how can you have 1 system with two different username formats? The macros (%u, %l, %d) are expanded exactly the same way as they are in the RC core, I am not going to change this. If you have multiple username formats then I suggest you put a check if the config and do it differently for the different formats or add the change you suggested to your copy of the plugin - but then you have to remember to add it again if you upgrade to a newer version.

[dziobak]

OK thanks, but could you help me with the main problem with sa-learn?

[JohnDoh]

sorry i dont really know anything about sa-learn

[Martian]

Several people have had the same problem you are with sa-learn not learning the mail (thus why I linked the thread above).  As far as I know, nobody has figured it out yet.

Sounds like you are further along than I ever got with it though.

Martian

[dziobak]

I think we can do it, but first there is something wrong with cmd_learn.php.
When i try use sa-learn i debug mode

Code Select Expand

'/usr/local/bin/sa-learn -D --username=test --spam ...' in markasjunk log i see command with '-D' parameter, but in array there is only one line

Code Select Expand

0 => 'Learned tokens from 0 message(s) (1 message(s) examined)', but should be much much more...

$tmp_command = str_replace('%f', $tmpfname, $command);
exec($tmp_command, $output);

IMO the $output should have every line that the exec function returns, but it haven't. When we will have full logging we will figure it.

[JohnDoh]

when using the -D option you need to add `2>&1` to the end of you command (eg: `sa-learn -spam %f 2>&1` to redirect standard error to standard output, it will then show up in the markasjunk2 debug log file.

[dziobak]

when using the -D option you need to add `2>&1` to the end of you command (eg: `sa-learn -spam %f 2>&1` to redirect standard error to standard output, it will then show up in the markasjunk2 debug log file.

Thanks JohnDoh for advice, I have totally forgotten about this.

I have the answer :-)
when running this command from markasjunk2, sa-learn doesn't know where is bayes database. So I have added --dbpath parameter and it works :-)

Code Select Expand

'/usr/local/bin/sa-learn --username=%u --dbpath /root/.spamassassin/ --configpath=/usr/local/etc/mail/spamassassin/ --spam %f'

[fritz001]

Thanks JohnDoh for advice, I have totally forgotten about this.

I have the answer :-)
when running this command from markasjunk2, sa-learn doesn't know where is bayes database. So I have added --dbpath parameter and it works :-)

Code Select Expand

'/usr/local/bin/sa-learn --username=%u --dbpath /root/.spamassassin/ --configpath=/usr/local/etc/mail/spamassassin/ --spam %f'

your spamassassin is missconfigured::

add this line to local.cf

bayes_path = /root/.spamassassin/bayes

and you don't have to add --dbpath